About Erwin Insurance Agency
Independent, local, and built on relationships. We help families and businesses in Middleburg, Jacksonville, and across Northeast Florida find the right coverage at the right price.
Independent means we work for you
As an independent insurance agency, Erwin Insurance is not tied to a single carrier. We shop multiple top-rated insurance companies to compare coverage and pricing, then recommend the option that actually fits your needs — not the one that benefits our bottom line.
Whether you need auto insurance for a new driver, homeowners coverage for a Clay County home, or a complete commercial package for a growing Jacksonville business, our agents take the time to explain your options and make sure you are not over- or under-insured.
Two offices, one company
Erwin Insurance Agency is part of the Erwin Insurance family, with offices in Middleburg and Jacksonville. Both locations share the same commitment to personal service, honest advice, and fast claims support.
- Middleburg Office2494 Blanding Blvd, Suite 9, Middleburg, FL 32068 — (904) 282-7212
- Jacksonville OfficeVisit www.erwininsurance.com — (904) 514-8500
Why clients choose us
Local agents
Real people in Middleburg who know Florida insurance firsthand.
Carrier choice
Multiple top-rated companies means more options for you.
Fast quotes
Most quotes are ready in minutes, not days.
Claims help
We walk with you through the claims process from start to finish.
Ready to work with a local agent?
Call, visit, or request a free quote and see why Middleburg families and businesses trust Erwin Insurance.